MarCeeJay Sport Fishing Customer Reviews

Name: MarCeeJay Sport Fishing
Brand: MarCeeJay Sport Fishing
Rating: 5 (2 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 2
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain John Raguso consistently delivers outstanding fishing experiences through his extensive knowledge of local waters and fish species. Customers praise his ability to locate the best fishing spots for catching a variety of species, with his expertise ensuring successful trips for anglers of all skill levels. His deep understanding of the area's marine life and proven techniques help guests achieve impressive results on every outing. Guests consistently highlight John's exceptional hospitality and family-friendly approach that makes every trip memorable. From the moment customers board his boat, he and his crew ensure everyone feels comfortable and well-equipped for the day ahead. Families particularly appreciate how he creates enjoyable experiences for children, with many young anglers having blast throughout their adventures. Customers frequently plan return visits and enthusiastically recommend John to friends and family members.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Knowledgeable

Comfortable

Successful

Variety

Species

Family

Organized

Recommended

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Gregg Porter

September 9, 2026

Trip - Full Day Guided Offshore Fishing Trip on Long Island's East End - Tuna, Marlin, Sharks and More on September 9, 2026

My buddy and I wanted to catch tuna. Captain John had a plan, patience and drive. He also has an amazingly seaworthy boat and years of experience to share. We caught 15 tuna (mostly false albacore) on an amazing one day trip. Captain John wasn't satisfied with 13 false albacore. He wanted us to reel in some table-worthy tuna. So, nearing the end of the day, rather than zipping back to port, he recommended that we troll our way back and maybe catch something along the path. So we did. And it worked. His knowledge, patience and tenacity paid off and we landed two beautiful yellowfin. We also experienced whales as well as sea turtles and container ships. All up close and personal. We were exhausted but thrilled after experiencing an incredible day of offshore fishing. Thanks John! We'll be back!

Was this helpful ?

Emily West

January 12, 2021

Trip - on January 12, 2021

I would highly recommend Captain John to anyone looking for a fun, successful, and well-organized fishing trip. We had fun!

Was this helpful ?

NY's Premier Light Tackle Charter

MarCeeJay Sport Fishing Reviews – Top-Rated Montauk Fishing Charters

See why anglers rave about MarCeeJay Sport Fishing! Our Montauk fishing charters are known for expert guidance, top-quality equipment, and unforgettable experiences on the water. Whether you're battling striped bass, tuna, or mahi-mahi, our guests consistently leave glowing reviews about our professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to customer satisfaction. Read firsthand accounts from anglers of all skill levels who have enjoyed exciting days on the Atlantic Ocean, Long Island Sound, and Gardiners Bay with Captain John.

See What Anglers Say About Their Montauk Fishing Experience

From seasoned anglers to first-time fishermen, our guests love the action-packed fishing and expert instruction they receive on every trip. Our reviews highlight the best of inshore, offshore, and deep-sea fishing charters, showcasing the thrill of reeling in trophy fish with an experienced captain at the helm. Whether you’re booking a private charter for family fun or a serious sport fishing adventure, our five-star reviews reflect our commitment to delivering the best fishing experience in Montauk, NY.